The Wall Street Journal just came out with a great article about booster seats safety. According to a study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety and the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute, a number of booster seats don't do enough to protect children in a crash and could even contribute to internal injuries. Here are some excerpt from the article.
"In a report released today, the Insurance Institute said 13 of the 41 booster seats it tested performed so poorly that it can't recommend them. The research group, which is funded by the insurance industry, said it considers 10 models the "best bets," and five more models are good bets. The rest are fair.
Another key finding: Children's proportions and vehicle designs vary so much that even a good booster can be misused. Parents should make sure that a booster fits their child and their car before buying the seat.
Boosters are designed for children -- typically ranging from about 4 to 9 years old -- who are too big for toddler restraints but still too small to use adult safety belts alone. Most toddler seats are for kids who weigh up to 40 pounds. A booster seat is supposed to raise the child so the vehicle's belts rest properly across the pelvis and chest. A poor fit can result in the lap belt resting against the abdomen and causing internal injuries in a crash. Shoulder belts can cause injuries if they are too high and stretch across a passenger's neck.
The best bets, according to the study, include the Fisher-Price Safe Voyage, the Britax Parkway, the LaRoche Bros. Teddy Bear, the backless Graco TurboBooster, the backless Combi Kobuk and the Recaro Young Style. Some high-back seats convert to backless designs, so the group tested the configurations separately. The Safeguard Go made the "best bets" list when used in its backless mode, and the highback versions of the Volvo booster and Britax Monarch made the list. Adrian Lund, president of the insurance group, says he'd expect the seats in this group to improve seat-belt fit for children in nearly any vehicle.
The main problem with the boosters that the group doesn't recommend is that they place the lap belt on the child's vulnerable abdomen. The list includes the Cosco/Dorel Summit, Traveler and Alpha Omega, the Cosco Highback Booster, the Graco CarGo Zephyr, the Evenflo Generations and Evenflo Chase Comfort Touch, and the Compass B505 and B510. Also, the Dorel/Safety 1st Prospect and Intera, as well as the Evenflo Big Kid Confidence, were in the worst list when used in highback versions, and the Safety Angel Ride Ryte was when used backless.
Dorel Juvenile Group says its seats "meet or exceed all federal regulations." Graco also said its products meet "all relevant regulations."
Still, safety experts say the risk of injury to a child is less likely with a booster -- even a less-effective model. "What we don't want to do is to somehow make parents think that boosters don't work, because they do," says Kristy Arbogast, director of engineering at the Center for Injury Research and Prevention at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. According to the hospital's research, booster seats reduce children's risk of injury in a crash by 59%.
At the same time, a good rating doesn't guarantee a proper fit. Different back-seat angles, for instance, can change the way seat belts fit children."
Bottom line, don't rely on what a manufacturer has to say about their seat, but rather listed to an objective opinion from a certified car seat safety specialist before purchasing a booster seat for your child. Click here to speak to one of our
certified car seat installation specialist and child proofing expert.
